supermarkets: love them or hate them?

The big supermarkets are here to stay, and they are very convenient. I remember trying to buy fresh veg on a Sunday – you just couldn’t in the early 80s, so I’m glad those days are over. But supermarkets have led to the loss of many independent shops and killed off variety in the high street. Have we lost the balance?

Did you know that 85% of the money we spend on food is spent in supermarkets? This gives them a huge power over us happy shoppers, as well as suppliers and governments. We think supermarkets give us loads of choice – but are we really the ones in control?


I went to a very interesting debate about supermarkets on Thursday, hosted by The Guild of Food Writers. Alex Renton, Tim Hayward and Zoe Williams put forward their strong views, refereed by Sheila Dillon from Radio 4’s The Food Programme. The setting of Portcullis House gave it some gravitas, as portraits of past and present PMs lined the coridoors. Andrew Opie, from the British Retail Consortium and Sophie Bambridge from Barfoots, a large vegetable supplier explained some of the reasons why supermarkets operate in the way they do.


Alex Renton argued that farmers are forced to pay the cost of the supermarkets’ price war. When customers demand cheaper food, the costs are paid elsewhere. Small scale farming is dying out, animal welfare gets worse, and we eat more processed food which creates strain on the NHS. He argued that European co-operatives are the answer, giving more power back to the producers.

Alex also pointed out that the supermarkets aren’t always cheaper – they just say they are! Often local shops offering local produce are much cheaper. Don’t believe everything they tell you!


Andrew Opie said supermarkets simply give customers what they want. If we shop according to price, we get cheap food. When we ask for free-range, we get that.


Tim Hayward, a former ad man and now journalist said advertising has a massive impact and every article that tells us “we are too busy to cook” does us a disservice by making cooking seem like a chore. Wet then pay a premium for ready meals and processed food. Apparently the average Brit adult watches 30 hours of TV a week, so how can they justify that they are too busy to shop around and cook fresh food? He argued that feminism is to blame: if cooking is seen as domestic drudgery, the answer was found in processed convenience food. Generations have not learnt to cook.


Zoe Williams responded by saying that women are too busy to cook, working as well as still doing most of the household chores. Many men claim they cannot cook, and those that do only have time to cook chef-style on the weekend, leaving family cooking and shopping to the women. It created a debate: I think this could be a generation and regional thing.


Sophie Bambridge explained the supply chain and how tough each supermarket negotiate on price, with Tesco being the most bullish. The story of asparagus being flown in this year made the newspapers; she explained that the UK asparagus was late but the slot was allocated in each supermarket, so they had to fly in asparagus to fill the shelves. The sheer scale of supermarkets means they cannot respond to seasonal variations.


I find most supermarkets gloomy, cluttered places and I try to avoid them. The worst are the ones with entrances lined with cheap muffins, made with trans-fats, as the fake bakery smell pumps over you. Rows of processed ready meals and cereals are depressing too. Bread that has been ‘baked in store’ but uses cheap ingredients, fat and stabilisers. Co-op and Watirose tend to be better – more focus on fresh ingredients, and less on processed foods. There are plenty of healthy products to find in any supermarket: free-range eggs, organic milk, British fruit and vegetables, but you have to be tough to ignore the junk. The alternatives are markets, delivery schemes and shopping local. The French manage it; we have just got in to some very strange habits.


About thelocalfoodie

Food writer for The Herts Advertiser.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to supermarkets: love them or hate them?

  1. MichelleLake says:

    This is a fabulous post Becky- great to draw attention to the power that the supermarkets hold over all of us. It’s wonderful that you highlight all the fabulous alternatives we have available to us in our local area in your blog. I generally find supermarkets soulless uninspiring places which provide an unpleasant shopping experience when compared to markets and local shops. Interaction with shopkeepers and stall holders when buying fresh seasonal food; swapping cooking ideas and local gossip makes you feel so much happier and motivated to cook than traipsing round brightly aisles. Personally I prefer to get my “boring shopping” delivered and then supplement with a veggie box, the market and local shops. That way you avoid the temptation of unhealthy BOGOFs!

  2. Andrei says:

    Good post Becky,
    Plenty of hot potatoes here…
    Eat local where possible, eat less high protein as our bodies don’t need it and the planet will have a chance and finally make food less elitist. Tv adds don’t help but we must return to the old way where it starts in the home, reiterated in the school and supported by legislation all the way. NHS& the planet will suffer in the end . All because we demand mangoes as and when and dont relise that its totally unacceptable to eat meat/fish that is farmed without welfare. Supermarkets control we’re too busy to argue & time marches on.
    Make time, cook from fresh, appreciate the value of food and the table & finally make an effort to eat more simply.

  3. Completely agree Andre. Eating more pulses would bring shopping bills down and be very good for health. And definitely agree with Michelle’s view that food shopping at markets is good for the soul – getting outside and talking to stall holders is so much nicer than being in a supermarket.

  4. Pingback: Co-Op: Not Good with Customer Service « Dave Farmer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s